Op-Eds Speaking Truth to the Powers-That-Be

The Water’s Fine in a Single Health Care Insurance Pool

Water's Fine in a Single Insurance Pool

Yet another delay in the implementation of the Affordable Care Act (ACA): Medium-sized businesses, those with 50 to 99 workers, will get another year’s grace period before they must offer health insurance to their employees.

In July, the White House pushed the start date for small businesses with fewer than 50 workers to 2015.

Here’s a question: With all the negative press about Obamacare, from both the Right and the Left, why has there been virtually no serious discussion about the benefits of decoupling health insurance from employment once and for all?

Historically, post World War II wage controls prompted the rise of employer-sponsored health coverage. Not considered part of wages by the IRS, health care and sick leave were offered as so-called “fringe benefits” to attract workers. Employees didn’t have to pay taxes on these benefits; their employers got tax write-offs – a win/win at the time.

That was then, and a lot has changed since the 1940’s. These changes predate the ACA:

Few, if any, Americans graduating from college since the 1990’s can count on more than a few years of employment with one company, let alone the lifetime employment that their grandfathers and perhaps some of their fathers enjoyed.

According to the Bureau of Labor and Statistics, the average worker in this country will job-hop 15 to 20 times before retirement!

At the same time that employment has become less stable, healthcare costs have outpaced inflation.  Large companies with entrenched healthcare benefits departments, a huge administrative cost,  have been reconfiguring health care policies for decades, looking to trim expenses.

Often the results are less comprehensive health plans and/or higher deductibles and co-pays. Many employers, big and small, choose to hire temporary rather than full time workers to eliminate the need to provide health care insurance at all. They argue (rightly) that they now have to compete with companies around the world that don’t foot the bill for their employees’ health care.

All of this has occurred as the power of unions to protect worker wages and benefits has declined.

Because 60 percent of Americans still get health insurance through their employers, however inadequate it may be, self-employed and temporary workers do not have the same purchasing power in the marketplace. Their premiums are much higher for the same coverage. Of course, that is assuming that they could even get a policy,  since the pre-ACA world’s insurance company usually denied any health related issue considered to be a pre-existing condition.

In a 2009 New York Times op ed, Princeton economist Uwe Reinhardt said: “Ask any group of health policy experts whether they would have put in place our employment-based health insurance system, had they had the luxury of designing our health system from scratch, the resounding answer most likely would be ‘No.’”

One alternative he suggested in another op-ed was rolling back the Medicare eligibility age to allow Americans younger than 65 to buy into the program.

Unfortunately, insurance companies, fearing the potential loss of huge numbers of customers exposed to a more efficient system like Medicare, successfully lobbied Congress. The result: leading Democrats like Max Baucus and Harry Reid, who claimed to favor a public option ultimately closed off any discussion of even this limited approach. The Right, ostensibly champions of capitalism and free markets, successfully demonized a true public option by labeling it “Socialism”.

The current system is anything but a free market model. Within most states today, only a very small number of huge insurers dominate. This means that the 40 percent of people not covered by their employers have less bargaining power and fewer options when purchasing healthcare on their own.

In a recent analysis, the American Medical Association (AMA) found that in 71 percent of local markets across America, a single insurance company controlled half or more of those markets.

According to the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation, more than half the people who purchase individual insurance policies in 30 states are limited to a single insurance company.

Some argue that large monopolies are not inherently bad if they are able to negotiate lower premiums. Others, like the AMA, cite national studies showing that when insurance companies merge and acquire smaller companies, their profits and premiums go up.

Even if some monopolies do deliver lower premiums, isn’t the cornerstone of capitalism anti-monopoly, pro-competition?

Doesn’t it make more sense to put everyone in the same insurance pool? That would create a truly competitive health insurance environment. Insurance companies then would all be vying for the individual consumer, forcing transparency and driving costs down.

Freed from covering healthcare for their workers, employers could compete in the global marketplace. Employees who joined their companies would do so because they wanted to be there, not because health benefits were offered. Others might choose to become their own bosses, spurring a renewed growth of entrepreneurs and future job creators. A win/win for capitalism.

So, given the newest delay in the employer mandate, and given the fact that the Right, anxious to repeal Obamacare once and for all, wants to extend this delay to individuals in the name of “fairness”, perhaps the time is ripe to have a serious national discussion about really reforming the healthcare system by starting with elimination of employer-based healthcare.

About Deborah Shlian

Deborah Shlian is a physician, medical consultant and author of numerous non-fiction articles and books as well as three published novels co-authored with her husband Joel (Double Illusion, Wednesday’s Child and Rabbit in the Moon). Rabbit in the Moon, an international thriller, won the 2008 Gold Medal, Florida Book Award, ForeWord Magazine's Silver Award for best mystery, the Royal Palm Literary Award and Honorable Mention for best Audiobook for the San Francisco Book Festival. Deborah is co-author with Dr. Linda Reid, of the Sammy Greene thriller series. Dead Air, the first in the series won the 2010 Royal Palm Literary Award for Best Thriller. Devil Wind, the second in the series, won the Hollywood Book Award for best Audiobook and the 2011 Royal Palm Literary Award for Best Thriller. "Deep Waters", the third in the series was released in 2019. "Silent Survivor" by Deborah Shlian is a stand-alone medical mystery/thriller that has won the 2018 Royal Palm Literary Award among several other awards. Her nonfiction book, "Lessons Learned: Stories from Women in Medical Management" was released in March, 2013. After 25 years in Los Angeles, Deborah and her husband now reside in Boca Raton, Florida.

3 comments on “The Water’s Fine in a Single Health Care Insurance Pool

  1. Joan Cochran
    February 19, 2014

    Year ago, I ran a small hotel and restaurant supply company with five employees and the insurance ate up a huge chunk of our profits … and my time. It would’ve so much easier to simply pay our employees and let them seek the right insurance for them, which presumably would be available under a single pay system.

  2. Deborah Shlian
    February 19, 2014

    Apropos my assertion that the Right now wants to delay the individual mandate, legislation has just been introduced to do just that:

  3. Sandra Walters
    February 20, 2014

    Thank you for your ideas re a more intelligent approach to health insurance. If healthcare was no longer an employment benefit, it would definitely make American businesses more competitive. With one insurance pool for all, it is also likely to lower health care premiums through competition. I also liked your idea of lowering the age for Medicare. All your proposals seem to have the potential to improve a health care system that needs improving.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s


This entry was posted on February 19, 2014 by in Affordable Care Act, Health Care Reform and tagged .

The Past on T2P

Stay Connected.

Catch up. Catch on! Text T2Power to 22828!

Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Top Posts & Pages

Women Docs as Leaders: We’re Still a 16 Percent Ghetto
U.S. Economy 101 (in Plain English, with Humor!): How the GOP and the Media Are Shucking You
The Koch Brothers Contango Strategy: Oil Prices as Political WMD Against Obama
In Guns We Trust
The More Movie Critics Think They Know About "Now You See Me," the Less They Know

Get Forward Thinking

Sign up here for Forward Thinking, a monthly newsletter delivered to your email box with special features from the various RossGroupFT publications, including new titles from RossBooksFT.
For Email Marketing you can trust

Copyright Notice

The (T2P) website and all text, design and artwork elements not part of the standard WordPress template or an article, and all T2P logos and trademarks are copyright ©2011 and future years by TheRossGroupFT, LLC. All rights reserved. All articles' text is the copyright of its author. T2P is a forum for free speech of its invited authors, and the opinions and information that they present are their own. TheRossGroupFT, its principals, agents and assigns are not responsible for the opinions or content of any article.
TheRossGroupFT - Forward Thinking for New Media

Writing for T2P

We're looking for passionate, out-of-the-box, outside-the-Beltway writing and thinking. To find out more about how to audition your work for us, click here.

Follow t2PTweets on Twitter!

About Truth-2-Power

A phrase coined by the Quakers during in the mid-1950's, "Speak truth to power," was a call for the United States to stand firm against fascism and other forms of totalitarianism; it is a phrase that seems to unnerve political right, with reason. The Founding Fathers of United States risked their lives in order to speak truth to the power of King George and the mighty British Empire. It was and is considered courageous. Join us!

The Forward Thinking Store

The t2p Tee

Get your t2p gear at the Forward-Thinking Store

Share us on LinkedIN

%d bloggers like this: